|
Hi, I didn't know that. That is great! I hope he replies to this. Firstly, I have not downloaded the dvds. I was just thinking, since the copyrighted material is in digital form, there is essentially a limitless supply. The copyright laws are to protect the income of the creator. Since the struggling student would not otherwise buy the dvds, the income remains the same whether the student downloads them or not. It only becomes an issue when those who can afford to buy the dvds decide to download the torrent. I completely understand the copyright laws and why they are in place, I am just suggesting that the creator should be okay, ethically, with sharing the resource with someone for free, if it does not have any negative impact on them. - and the negative impact only comes when those with money download it. I know this has no practical applications, since it would be impossible to implement, but in theory and for argument's sake - Maybe some of the ethics/philosophy experts can clear up what ethical requirements the creator has in this case to someone who can not afford to buy but would benefit greatly from, a limitless resource.
|